Jeep Tire Buying Guide

Updated on Jan 11, 2024

While buying tires may seem like a rudimentary task, especially after researching lift kits, body armor, and every other modification stuffed under the hood, chassis, and hardtop of your Jeep, it’s not as simple as selecting the tire that looks the most aggressive or puts the smallest dent in your wallet. Selecting the proper tire for your application takes serious research and thought; after all, who’d want to spend thousands of dollars on a product that doesn't suit your needs? 

Luckily, the team at RealTruck has you covered. In this article, we’re tackling Jeep tire selection, including the types of tires you'll encounter on the market and the essential factors to consider when selecting your next set of meats. Let’s get started! 


Why Are Tires So Important?

Tires are one of the most essential purchases for any vehicle, especially a Jeep Wrangler or CJ; but why exactly?  

Tires are your Jeep’s exclusive connection with the road or trail, determining its handling characteristics over various terrain types. They’re also the primary source of traction, both on and off-road. The pattern of a tire’s tread and sidewall, paired with its compound, directly informs how your Jeep claws through obstacles, grips wet pavement, maintains stability at high speeds, and performs in practically every other driving condition; hence, their significance! 

So, what differentiates one tire from the next? Let’s take a look at the most popular tire types you’ll encounter when purchasing tires for your Jeep. 


Tire Styles

When browsing tires for your Jeep Wrangler or CJ, you’ll typically come across four key types: highway, all-terrain, hybrid-terrain, and mud terrain. Each style has unique characteristics that gear it towards a particular terrain type; depending on your Jeep’s use, one type likely suits your needs better than the others.


Highway Tires

Highway tires, like the Nitto Dura Grappler, are one of the more common tire types, traditionally installed from the factory on passenger cars, base model Jeeps, and two-wheel-drive pickups. These tires are geared toward on-road comfort, traction, and longevity, featuring multiple small tread blocks, elaborate siping, mild sidewall patterns, and firm tread compounds.  

Manufacturers extensively test highway tires to ensure a smooth, quiet, and comfortable product that lasts tens of thousands of miles, typically in the range of 55,000–65,000. However, these tires do come with notable drawbacks, especially for Jeeps. 

Highway tires don’t provide much traction off-road, making them a poor candidate for Jeeps that regularly see dirt, mud, sand, and other challenging terrains. They also typically utilize thinner sidewalls with fewer plies, making them more prone to tears and punctures on the trail. 

While ideal for daily driving and dedicated street use, our next style is far superior for mixed highway/off-road driving.


All-Terrain Tires

All-Terrain tires, like the Toyo Open Country A/T III, are popular and highly versatile, commonly installed on pickups, SUVs, and–you guessed it–Jeeps. These tires excel in nearly all terrain conditions, including wet/dry pavement, loose dirt, gravel, and snow. While they aren’t known for providing exceptional traction in deep mud, they’re an excellent option for mild wheeling. 

All-terrain tires are characterized by their moderately aggressive tread patterns and sidewalls, allowing them to claw through challenging terrain more efficiently than similar highway-terrain tires. However, they also feature some qualities that overlap with highway tires, such as smaller tread blocks, siping, and relatively firm compounds. The result is a tire that’s competent off-road but also provides excellent on-road performance and longevity–typically around 40,000–45,000 miles.  

All-terrain tires are ideal for daily drivers, mild wheelers, and weekend warriors; they’re perfect for those who drive primarily on the street but enjoy occasional wheeling.

Mud-Terrain Tires

Mud-terrain tires, like the Falken Wildpeak M/T, are engineered for use in the harshest terrains, like trudging through deep mud and bouncing over boulders. This style is characterized by large tread blocks, aggressive shoulders, minimal siping, and thick puncture-resistant sidewalls, making them a must-have for dedicated wheelers; however, on-road performance typically suffers. 

Mud-terrain tires are considerably louder than all-terrain and highway tires on the street, causing moderate humming and even vibrations at high speeds. They also utilize softer compounds, resulting in dramatically quicker wear than the previous two styles–typically 30,000–35,000 miles. 

Mud-terrain tires are ideal for the dedicated wheeler, show rig, or weekend cruiser; however, we’d opt for an all-terrain if you frequently drive on pavement.

Hybrid-Terrain Tires

If you noticed, there’s a significant difference between mud-terrain and all-terrain tires, producing a gap in the market for those that want a stickier tire than an all-terrain but better longevity and road manors than a mud-terrain. While this was the case for decades, the past ten years have shown immense improvements in tire tech, and with these improvements came hybrid-terrain tires, like the Nitto Ridge Grappler

Hybrid-terrain tires blend the characteristics of these two common tire types, featuring aggressive shoulders and sidewalls like a mud-terrain, but a more compact center tread section with numerous smaller tread blocks, like an all-terrain. The result is a tire that easily cuts through extreme terrain, but offers excellent driving characteristics on the street!

These tires are ideal for Jeeps that see around 50/50 street and trail usage.

Tire Sizing

Proper sizing is crucial when selecting your Jeep’s new meats; however, you can’t simply size up willy-nilly based on some rudimentary measurements with a tape measure or what the sixteen-year-old tire jockey behind the counter of your local shop recommends. Several variables determine tire sizing, including: 

  • Your Jeep’s generation/model

  • Your Jeep’s suspension modifications

  • Your Jeep’s body modifications

  • Your Jeep’s primary use

  • Your Jeep’s differential gear ratios

  • The dimensions of your Jeep’s wheels (width, offset, etc.)


It’s crucial to select a tire size that compliments the other components of your Jeep build; for instance, if your Jeep is running stock wheels and suspension, stick to a tire that’s equivalent or close to factory sizing. If your Jeep has a mild lift or leveling kit, you can likely bump up an inch or two height and width-wise. However, if your Jeep is running a massive lift with high-clearance fenders, stubby bumpers, and 5.13 gears, slap on the largest tire that grants full articulation! 

For additional information on tire sizing, including recommended sizing for alternative lifts and wheel sizes, check out our Jeep Wrangler Tire Selection Guide on RealSource, your source for all things truck, Jeep, and SUV!


Which Tires Are Right For My Jeep?

Accounting for all of the above information, how do you decide which tires are right for your Jeep? The truth is, every Jeep is different, as are their owners and driving styles. There’s no one-size-fits-all tire; if it were that simple, we wouldn’t have so many types and sizes to choose from!

We recommend taking things one step at a time, using your available resources for tips and advice, like fellow Jeepers, forums, and your experts at RealTruck! Take some measurements and select an ideal tire size, analyze your driving style and select your preferred tire type, then browse our available tires that fit your needs! And if you’re still having trouble making a selection, don’t hesitate to contact the experts.


VIDEO: Tire Differences | Wheels Tips

Shop Now

RealTruck is your home for the best products to outfit your build for unforgettable adventures.

Wheels and Rims | Bumpers | Interior Lights | Exhaust Systems

Join over 2 million RealTruck people

Get exclusive savings, insider information, and the latest RealTruck articles sent straight to your inbox.